Showing posts with label Free-to-Play. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Free-to-Play. Show all posts

Sunday, June 29, 2014

Enigma Express Game Review




Hidden object and free-to-play games are not usually high on my list of interesting. However, hidden object games are something that my wife seems to enjoy so when I saw that Relentless Software released Enigma Express for iOS devices and it was free, I decided to give it a test drive. Enigma Express is set in the same world as Relentless Software's other mystery puzzle game, Murder Files. You are a junior detective trying to help Hannah Dakota of the Blue Toad Agency figure out why mysterious objects have been stolen from the bank deposit box of a notorious criminal.

The game is played out by finding hidden objects at various locations. Press on the object hidden on the screen to earn points. The higher points total you have when time runs out, the better. Points help unlock clues that are then used to unlock the next location in the game. A total of 5 clues can be earned at each location - earning additional clues also gives you more time to find objects the next time you play through that location. Some locations have you searching for up to 4 objects at once, adding a new object to find for each one you have already found. Other locations have different variations where you are looking for a single object at time and have to find it before being given another object. There is also a hint system that is on a timer, so you won't be able to use it more than once or twice a try. In the background you have the cut scene (somewhat) interactive story bits that tell you the underlying story of Enigma Express. 



Those are the nuts and bolts of the game, but then you run into the free-to-play elements. Each time you go to a location, you use 20 energy to begin the object search mini-game. Energy is replenished over time with 1 energy coming back every few minutes. If you need a quicker influx of energy, you can always buy some with coins. You earn coins periodically through the game or can buy them with actual $$. When you use clues to unlock a new location, there is a timer while train tracks are being laid to get you there (typically a few minutes) or if you don't want to wait, you can use coins to finish the track instantly. 



What works well with this game is the quirky story, art and voice acting. There is a lot of polish to this game and finding the objects within the 1 - 2 minutes you get for a level can be a challenge at times. This certainly could have been a premium game on the App Store and no one would have blinked an eye. They also have allowed the ability to login into Facebook and have leaderboards with your Facebook friends. 




Where things breakdown for me is in the Facebook integration, loading issues and free-to-play elements. I would much rather have paid a few dollars to have the game without the timers than to be kept from playing the game every 10 minutes or so when I run out of energy. I also don't like that I am asked to connect to Facebook after I finish any hidden-object mini game try - I don't have a Facebook account and don't need to see that pop-up every couple of minutes. It would be nice if there was an option to turn off all of those pop-ups. It would also be nice to be able to pay to remove the timers and coins so that the game can just be played and the story enjoyed. Probably the hardest thing to get over is how long it takes for the game to load up when you first open the app. Sometimes it seems to hang and you have to clear it from memory and re-open the app to get to play. This may just be due to the capabilities of my gen 1 iPad mini being on the weak side for the game, but it is compatible back to iOS 4.3, so there may be a lot of older devices trying to run it. 

You may see this for a while.

I think all the elements for a fun little game are here, but the timers and pop-ups and loading times are killing it for me. Hopefully some of these items will be addressed in updates down the road. For all the quirky polish that goes into the Murder Files games, I would like to see them succeed. I give Enigma Express 3 Mick Happies as a free-to-play hidden object game, just know what your in for before spending too much time with it. Now I need to go spend some time with all of the other games I just bought during the Steam Summer Sale. 


Sunday, December 1, 2013

Flick Kick Football Legends Review (Updated)



I played a lot of Flick Kick Football from Pik Pok on my iPod. When I saw that they were releasing a new Flick Kick game called Flick Kick Football Legends (available for iOS and Android), I was certain I would pick it up and give it a try. The original game, typically $0.99 or $1.99, uses a 1970's shaded-cel feel with a swiping mechanic to shoot soccer balls at the goal. There are often players put in the way as obstacles that you have to bend kicks around. All in all, a fun game.



In Flick Kick Football Legends, Pik Pok has taken the same 70s feel and the flick mechanic and expanded it to a full game. With game clock running, you will use the flick mechanic to pass the ball to teammates and attempt to score. Hit an opposition player, they will steal the ball and then you have to use the flick mechanic to dispossess them before they score on you. There are also Nigel and Kevin, the announcers who share some witty reparte after every match.




The game also has a player card mechanic added - each of your team members have their own trading card that shows their level and special abilities (like making the goal a little wider, stronger shot or better bending ability on shots). You swap players in and out depending on the mix of abilities you want on the field. There are also different rarities of cards, which translate to more or fewer abilities for that player and also impact their level cap (basic cards start all maxed out with no abilities, commons have one ability and can level 3 times, uncommons have 2 abilities and can level up 6 times, etc.).



You play your team through various divisions, earning promotion to the next level by winning your league. The amateur league has fewer, easier opponents and each subsequent division has more opponents, stronger competition and more games to play before the season is over.



As with most free-to-play games, you can earn two types of in-game currency. Gold coins are earned for winning matches, 10,000 of them can be spent on a basic pack of 3 common (possibly one of which could be uncommon) cards. Cash is earned by winning your league and 250 cash can be spent on a pack 3 cards and at least 1 uncommon or better card. Or you can spend more cash for better packs. There is also a stamina counter that limits how many matches you can play in a row before you have to wait for the timer to finish its 30 minute countdown and the stamina bottle to refill a bit (1 game worth per 30 minutes). Oh and did I mention ads? They show up as well - as banners at the top of the screen and full page ads you have to click out of between halves or after matches. According to Pik Pok, the ads will go away after making an in-app purchase and rebooting the app.



It is these free-to-play elements that actually overwhelms an otherwise fantastic game. I understand wanting to make money off the great game you have made, but the constant ads, stamina timer, slow cash earnings limiting getting more players all detract from a great swiping game mechanic with cool card/player leveling system and game progression through seasons and promotion to new divisions.



Where Pik Pok could have gone is to make this a paid app (a couple dollars) and then still leave in the currencies. If you want to pay to get quick cash - go for it. If you want to play to earn what you can - do that. Oh and remove the stamina timer as all it does is make me stop playing the game. Or change it to a player stamina timer so you have to rotate players (available skills) for some matches or just wait until playing. If those things were changed, Flick Kick Football Legends would be a 4 or 5 Mick Happy game. As it is, it is at best a 3 Mick Happy game due to the interruptions, timers, etc. It is really too bad that a great game is hobbled by the implementation of free-to-play.



As an aside, I have taken it as a personal mission to progress as far as I can in the game without spending a dime due to the annoyance I have with the In-app Purchase and timers. Which is a shame as I would have spent 2 or 3 dollars on the game otherwise. For another free-to-play game that has in-app-purchases done right, you should check out Dr. Who: Legacy.